06 Oct 2007
Miracles are done by God and not by the individual soul (Jeeva). The Veda says that God alone does miracles (Satyakamah…). The logic in this point is that this entire creation is just His will. This world is just the imagination of God. You can do any impossible thing in your imaginary world. In that imaginary world, you can also make somebody who is created by you, to do anything. That somebody is able to do anything only due to your will. Hence, if somebody is doing a miracle, that somebody is not doing the miracle. God, the Creator of the world, is doing the miracle through him. Your will power is the material of your imaginary world and is responsible for any action that is natural as well as supernatural, within your imaginary world. Hence, for realized souls, who see every action as the will of God alone, the miracle is not a special action at all. For realized souls, not only the actions but also the entire material of the creation, is His will alone. In such a case they do not distinguish between matter, energy, work and miracle. Only ignorant people distinguish between miracle and ordinary action that can be done by human beings. They think that the human being can do such and such a work and God is not involved in it. Only for such people is a miracle necessary, since it is an action of God that can be separately distinguished from the action of a human being. This is the reason for realized souls not giving any importance to miracles; they see every action and even the entire world, as the action of God alone.
The human being itself is a work of God. Hence, the human being identified by life, mind or awareness, is called as Para Prakriti. ‘Prakriti’ means ‘best work’. Kriti means work. The prefix ‘Pra’ means ‘best’. This world is wonderful and hence is called as Prakriti or best work. Within this best work, life, mind or intelligence, denoting basic awareness, is again the best of the best. ‘Para’ means ‘best’. Para Prakriti means the best of the best work. Hence, life itself is work. Awareness is the basic material of life, mind or intelligence. In fact, awareness is the best special type of work done by the inert energy that is produced during the oxidation of food. This inert energy enters a special system called as the nervous system and does a special work. This special work is called as awareness. The effects of this special work are desires (Samkalpa) and discussions[1] of desires in various ways (Vikalpa), which together constitute the field of the mind. The final effect of this awareness or special work is intelligence, which takes a decision (Nishchaya). Life is Prana, or the oxygen maintained by the respiratory system, that is needed to oxidize the food taken by the digestive system. Life is present in plants. Mind requires a nervous system, which is developed in birds and animals. The main part of the nervous system is the brain, which is well developed in human beings. Even inert energy is a form of work alone. Matter, which is a form of inert energy, is also work. Hence, the entire creation involving matter, inert energy and awareness is just work. Any work requires the existence of a worker and the worker is God. Hence, the entire creation consisting of inert matter, inert energy, plants, birds, animals and human beings is just the work of God.
In this work of God (world), awareness (Chit) is the best work. If you say that awareness is modified into the world, science disproves it, since it is the inert energy that is modified into awareness. If you call God as awareness, we have no objection but the word used by you should not mean the awareness that is available in this world, which is generated by inert energy. Then the word used by you has no meaning and hence God becomes beyond the meaning available in the world, which means ‘unimaginable’. Hence, the link between God (worker) and the world (work) is unimaginable. In the world, you can find the imaginable worker and imaginable work alone. The link between two imaginable items becomes imaginable. The link between unimaginable God (worker) and the imaginable world (work) is unimaginable because such an example is not available in the world. Hence, our logic and imagination is limited to the creation only and not to the Creator and not even to the link that is the process of creation.
Now creation is imaginable even though its limits are unimaginable. But the deeper planes of this creation are unimaginable even to modern science. You cannot say that even the creation is entirely unimaginable. If everything is unimaginable, then the word unimaginable itself cannot be defined. If something is known and something is unknown, the known and unknown exist together. If the known disappears, then the unknown also disappears because both known and unknown are only relative to each other. Hence, God created the world and made the surface planes of the world to be known to us so that the relative unknown will also exist. Then alone can we say that God is unknown or unimaginable.
Again if God and the link between God and the world are completely unknown, then we will start with the world and end in the world alone.[2] This is what is being done by science. Science starts with the world and ends in the world. Its logic is limited to the world perfectly. If anybody tries to project a known item as unknown, science will object to it and we also must support science in this point. If you do some magic and say that it is a divine miracle, science opposes it and we must also support science and not the magic projected as a miracle. Therefore, you should always be scientific from all angles and try to disprove any miracle as magic. But if you really fail to prove the miracle as magic and yet keep arguing that the miracle was only magic, you are no more a scientist. You are in no way different from a blind ignorant fool who believes the magic to be a miracle. You are also a blind ignorant fool believing even a genuine miracle to be magic. We should be impartial enough to call both parties as conservative rigid fools bound to their blind beliefs. You should have always the open mind to analyze and accept the truth. You can prove the miracles of fraud Babas to be magic but you cannot say that the miracles of Shri Satya Sai Baba, which He has been doing since His childhood, are magic. Magic requires some training. In that tiny village of Puttaparti, in the childhood days of Baba, who came to train Baba in the art of magic? People would have noticed His training very easily and would have recorded the fact, since such things cannot remain hidden in such a small village.
Science is noble in admitting unknown things. Heisenberg is a noble scientist and the winner of the Nobel Prize. He admitted uncertain phenomena under the uncertainty principle. It is not certain whether the electron is a wave or a particle. It has a dual nature. Dual nature is not a precise answer and it admits the concept of uncertainty or unimaginable nature. According to science, inert energy is the basic material of this universe, which creates, maintains and finally dissolves the entire creation. This basic energy is the ‘God’ of science. The design of the world[3] does not require awareness because the theory of probability perfectly explains it by saying that a long enough duration of time has enabled the design of the world. Scientists do not accept the necessity of an intellectual agent to design this wonderful world as philosophers imagine in Vedanta (Brahma Sutras). If this were the end of the story, science could have easily disposed of the proposal of Vedanta and the scriptures could be easily concluded as poetic imaginations of certain poets. It can be easily concluded that certain people have created this poetry to exploit society in the name of God. Anyone can easily believe science and by this time the world would have been filled mostly with atheists, with theists in minority. But surprisingly, the majority is theistic and atheists are in minority.
Atheists say that since the majority is uneducated, theism exists due to the possibility of easy exploitation of uneducated people. But even among educated people, theists are in majority all over the world. What is the reason for this? The reason for this is that the unimaginable God is showing miracles in the lives of several people to establish the existence of unimaginable God. Not only this, but the unimaginable God is also exhibiting unimaginable miracles widely through several devotees and even demons. Not only this, but God is coming in human form and is offering the explanation of the miracles and the concept of God. Genuine miracles are many in the world and the minority of atheists is unable to dispose of these miracles as magic. You may write the correct answer by copying[4] in the examination. Somebody may have also written the same correct answer without copying in the examination. Since the answer is one and the same, can you say that the other person, who has written the correct answer, has also necessarily copied? The product may be the same but the methods of production can vary. Sodium chloride can be produced in several ways. You have produced it in one way. I have produced it in another way. The end product is the same sodium chloride. You cannot say that I have also produced it in your way alone. You may produce ash by hiding wet salt-powder in your hand. Shri Baba may produce the same ash by the materialization of will force. Since the ash is one and the same, you cannot say that Shri Baba must have also hidden the ash in His hand like you.
Baba is not recognized as God by mere miracles. He is recognized as God by divine knowledge which is special and cannot be heard anywhere (Prajnanam), by the divine love expressed through practical service, by the infinite bliss due to a balanced nature attained by entertaining oneself in any situation and finally by His miracles. The Veda gives these four identity marks for the human incarnation. Prajnanam Brahma[5], Raso vai sah[6], Anando Brahma[7] and Satyakamah[8] are the four corresponding Vedic statements that prove Him as God.
Miracles are very widely distributed in the world to give proof for the existence of God to every human being, which is the basic requirement. If you pray sincerely in a temple or even in an open place, generally God gives you His answer through a miracle. Many have witnessed this in their lives. Sometimes due to the inevitable fruits of your past deeds, God keeps silent for some time in spite of your prayers and that time is used for your transformation. Hence, scientists call this as probability or coincidence of events[9]. Hence, God demonstrates specific miracles through His human form, to meet this twisted interpretation of scientists or atheists. Even devotees and demons do specific miracles. God has given a wide coverage for spreading miracles since it involves the very basic issue of His existence. Scientists have to accept the existence of the unimaginable nature from the practical example of the unimaginable limits of this infinite universe. Scientists may reject miracles but they cannot reject the unimaginable limits of space. One instance of the existence of an unimaginable entity is sufficient to prove the existence of unimaginable God. Miracles act as supporting evidence of the same concept.
Cosmic Vision By Swami
I am provoked to cite another miracle of Lord Datta shown through this poor fellow (Me) about cosmic vision. On one day of Guru Purnima, I was giving a divine discourse to a small crowd of devotees in the house of Shri C. B. K. Murthy at Vijayawada. The speech went on for three hours. In the middle of the speech, I stood suddenly for five minutes closing My eyes. I do such things spontaneously and suddenly, without any plan or awareness of anything before, due to the will of God working through Me. I consider Myself to be most undeserving for such reasonless grace of God on Me. I never claim to be even a dust particle on the divine lotus feet of God. After five minutes, I opened My eyes and looked at two devotees sitting far from each other in the crowd. They were Shri Ajay and Smt. Sitamma. I asked both of them to explain about their vision. I told them that they should say whether they had the same vision or different. Both explained their visions separately and both visions happened to be the same. The vision was the same cosmic vision. Both saw the Lord with the entire universe in Him, standing before a golden chariot and both saw Arjuna fallen at the feet of the Lord. Previously, some devotees were reporting visions on seeing Me. But some were thinking that it might be an illusion of their own mind. Then how did both these devotees get the same vision at the same time? How could I ask only those two devotees, when several devotees were sitting there? You cannot dispose of every thing by mere probability and coincidence. It is by the grace of Shri Satya Sai Baba alone, that I give this divine knowledge and if any merit or miracle is exhibited, the credit of it goes only to Him. If any defect is seen, I own it. Some devotees consider Me too as a human incarnation of Lord Datta. But I sincerely feel that all My devotees are the real human incarnations of Lord Datta. I feel that Lord Datta is testing Me through them. He is seeing how much ego is injected into Me through their praise. I know that God will quit Me if the bad scented ego enters into Me as in the case of Parashurama. Shri Shiridi Sai Baba always maintained God in Him by resisting ego by always saying that God is the master (Allah Malik). Shri Satya Sai Baba also maintained God in Him constantly by saying that every human being is God already (Advaita).
Two Birds on a Single Tree
The human incarnation is God entering the human body as said by the Gita (Manusheem tanumashritam). The human body consists of three sub-bodies. The first is the external gross body made of five elements. The second is the internal subtle body (Jeeva), which is a bundle of qualities. The innermost is the causal body (Atman), which is pure awareness or the soul. Atman is like standstill water and qualities (Jeeva) are like the waves in the water. Jeeva and Atman are inseparable. Atman can exist without Jeeva, which is the steady soul in the meditation without thoughts. By effort, the thoughts (qualities) can be completely destroyed so that pure soul remains. This is the Nirguna-Atman (attributeless soul) of Advaita philosophers. But Jeeva cannot exist without Atman.
When God enters a human body, the Jeevatman, a jointly associated system of qualities and soul together, which is a liberated soul, exists there as a personal assistant. The Jeevatman is only a slave to God and can be considered as almost a living doll. The Veda refers to this as two birds living together on a common tree. The two birds are God and Jeevatman and the tree is the gross body of Jeevatman. God is the guest who has visited the house of the liberated soul. God does not enter a mere inert gross body. God lives with the liberated soul selected by Him from His family of liberated souls, so that the liberated soul becomes happy due to visit of God. God and the liberated soul are homogeneously united like two metallic components in the single phase of an alloy. God pervades even the gross body whenever it is required as in the situation of lifting up the hill by Lord Krishna. The human being consisting of the gross, subtle and causal bodies acts as a wire charged by electric current. The live wire can be treated as the current for all practical purposes. Hence, the human being is treated as God and this is the monism of Shankara. It is limited to the human incarnation and is not to be extended to every human being. In an ordinary human being, the soul and the Jeeva are the two birds as per Shankara and in that case, you can call the Jeeva as soul, but not as God. According to Ramanuja, the interpretation of the example is God and soul alone, but it is only with reference to the human incarnation.
The human incarnation proves the existence of the two components. The unimaginable God requires a medium, which is a part of creation, in order to express Himself to His devotees. The medium cannot be an inert statue because it cannot serve the purpose of preaching knowledge and directly receiving service from certain blessed souls.. The God component in Krishna preached the Bhagavat Gita, which is the scripture told by God. It is not called as Krishna Gita. When the war ended, Arjuna asked Krishna to repeat the Gita. Krishna expressed His inability but on compulsion, He preached the Anu Gita, which is not as good as the Bhagavat Gita. The Anu Gita is just a scholastic composition of Krishna, who had become a scholar under the training of Sandipa.
I have also experienced this situation several times. Whenever I give A divine discourse, it comes spontaneously from the God component in Me. Sometimes when a paragraph gets erased due to some technical fault in the computer, I become very much disturbed because I cannot repeat even a single sentence again! The two-component system proves Dvaita and since God is the major component and the soul is the minor component, it proves Vishishta Advaita. Thus, all the three theories co-exist simultaneously, differing only due to the angles of the observers. The highest devotees treat the human incarnation as God Himself, neglecting the Jeevatman, who is just a slave of God. The higher[10] devotees treat the human incarnation as almost God due to God being the major component. The normal devotees see God and Jeevatman separately in the human incarnation. The three devotees of the different levels simultaneously maintain their corresponding views of the human incarnation. Hence, all the theories of the three Acharyas are simultaneously correct.
The main problem with anybody is the repulsion between the common media due to ego and jealousy, which are the very nature of human beings. Souls in physical bodies on earth worship energetic bodies of God which are limited to the upper worlds, due to the absence of repulsion between common media. The energetic forms of God in the upper worlds like Vishnu are meant for the same souls which have entered energetic bodies after death on earth. The same soul becomes associated with an energetic body after death and goes to the upper world. Now the soul rejects the same energetic form of God, which it had worshipped tremendously when the soul existed on the earth, based on the same old repulsion between common media. Hence, the Gita says that even the soul going to Brahma Loka returns back to earth. But the human being worshipping the contemporary human incarnation must have crossed ego and jealousy here. Hence, such a soul on going to Brahma Loka, crosses the same repulsion there also and does not return back since he is always associated with God. The devotee worshipping energetic forms of God here, returns back from the abode of God, where as the devotee of Krishna, the contemporary human incarnation, does not return back. Here the word Krishna in the Gita should be taken as the contemporary human incarnation coming in every generation.
Hanuman did not worship statues of Vamana or Parashurama, the past human incarnations. He worshipped Rama, His contemporary human incarnation and became Brahma or God. Similarly the Gopikas worshiped their contemporary human incarnation, Krishna alone, and not the statue of Rama, the past human incarnation. They got Goloka, which is higher than the abode of God. Are you greater than Hanuman and the Gopikas to worship the statues of upper energetic forms like Vishnu or statues of past human incarnations like Krishna, and neglecting the present contemporary human incarnation of this generation, which is Shri Satya Sai Baba?
Jambavan, a bear, famous for foolish rigidity, could not recognize Krishna as God and fought with Him. Rama and Krishna differed in the external physiology of their gross bodies, which alone are visible. Even the internal qualities (subtle bodies) differed. The inner most causal body (pure awareness) of course cannot be God, because it even existed in Jambavan himself! The unimaginable God is invisible and is also beyond mental imagination and hence Jambavan could not recognize God in Krishna. God comes in human form in every generation to bless devotees; otherwise He becomes partial to only one generation. God can simultaneously exist in several human forms also, due to different programs in different places. Akkalkot Maharaj and Shiridi Sai Baba were simultaneous human incarnations of the same God, Datta.
God comes in human form for a multi dimensional program. He preaches divine knowledge covering all humanity including atheists. Miracles are mainly for atheists alone and some atheists have been converted into theists through the miracles of Baba. God receives the services of certain blessed devotees, who had done a lot of penance with that desire. He selects for His service only such a blessed soul, who has done a lot of penance in the past. The human incarnation mainly comes here only to fulfill the desire of such blessed devotees. Having come to earth for that purpose, He always tries to uplift all through the divine knowledge and miracles. The few exceptional blessed devotees are pleased to serve the Lord personally and see the pleasure on the face of the Lord, for which they did a lot of penance for several births. This is the main purpose of the visit of God in human form to earth.
Shri Shirdi Sai Baba used to say that He is the servant of God (Allah Malik). But He was God directly. Then why did He say that? The behavior of the human incarnation has a specific divine program with respect to humanity on earth. Generally human beings do not tolerate even a little greatness in another co-human being. Generally, when people are chatting with each other, you can find the tendency of each person to criticize everybody except himself or herself. In that case, how can humanity tolerate the greatest God in human form? They should be guided spiritually but every time the human incarnation takes care to pacify their jealousy and ego in every step of the guidance. Hence, the dualism of the human incarnation is an inevitable concept for humanity, leaving a few exceptional devotees of the top most level like the Gopikas. In the dual concept of the human incarnation, God and liberated soul co-exist together. It is the liberated soul present in the human incarnation that says “Allah Malik”. Moreover, God has to act as an ordinary human being first and then as a devotee to give practical guidance to humanity. The monism of the human incarnation is suitable to only a very few devotees like the Gopikas. Even if they hear “Allah Malik”, they are not disturbed by such statements due to their firm faith. Hence, God in human form always plans His program only according to the general humanity.
God as Divine Servant
A divine play is also arranged in which God takes both the roles of a human incarnation and a devotee, so that a practical demonstration of the selection and worship of the contemporary human incarnation can be given. Rama and Hanuman are an example of the incarnation and devotee respectively playing their roles simultaneously. God is the single actor in both the roles. You often find in a cinema that a single actor play a double role. For the Omnipotent God, nothing is impossible. Both Rama and Hanuman are human incarnations of God to establish the concept of the contemporary human incarnation. Similarly, Krishna and Radha are the same roles of God. Radha was the incarnation of Durvasa. Durvasa was an incarnation of Shiva. Krishna was an incarnation of Narayana. Both Shiva and Narayana are energetic incarnations of the same God and the Veda says the same thing. Similarly, Rama and Hanuman are the incarnations of Narayana and Shiva. Hence, sometimes you find two contemporary human incarnations playing in the roles of God and devotee simultaneously to give an effective message to humanity.
Sometimes God even becomes a devotee of a devotee since God says that He is the servant of His servant. You may keep a diamond on the floor and a gravel stone in the sky. The diamond will not become a stone and the stone will not become a diamond by virtue of the place. When Hanuman became a devotee of Rama or Radha became a devotee of Krishna, it is God in one role becoming the devotee of God in another role. But Shirdi Sai Baba became the disciple of Bade Baba for sometime. Here Sai Baba always remains God and Bade Baba always remains a devotee. God preaches us to be submissive and avoid ego at any cost by all these incidents. God in the role of Rama defeated God in the role of Parashurama and this is again a message for humanity that one should not become egoistic taking the credit of any work for himself.
Today people are fond of ego and praise from others. Everybody is a victim of the wine of praise. Some like it externally but everybody likes it internally. While giving a message to humanity, God also is entertained in the variety of roles. Lord Shiva is called as Ishvara, which means that He is the Master of every soul in creation. He became bored with the continuous role of the Master and became very fond of the role of a servant. Hence, He enjoyed very much in the roles of Hanuman and Radha as devoted servants. But this aspect is only secondary and the primary aspect is to give an effective message to humanity. Hanuman never said that He is God. He was given the post of God by Rama. Hanuman was already God and now He becomes God again. In the role of Hanuman, God forgot that He is God. The Advaita philosophy applies completely only in the case of Hanuman. Advaita says that the soul is already God and forgot that it is God. Now by realization through spiritual knowledge (Maha Vakyas of Veda), the soul becomes God. Advaitins say that this is Prapta Prapti i.e., the attainment of the ‘already attained’. Now this concept applies to Hanuman perfectly. He is already God but has taken the role of Hanuman. He forgot Himself. Now after getting the post of God, He becomes God again. This is Prapta Prapti.
If an ordinary human being applies this concept to itself, such a human being is not Hanuman, but is a foolish petty monkey! Hence, there is every possibility of the devotee of a contemporary human incarnation to be God just like the contemporary human incarnation.
God Does Not Seek Devotees
God never projects Himself for the sake of praise, love or service from others. There is no trace of need for these for God, as in the case of a soul. All the sages and angels are constantly praising Him. Does He require the praise of these human beings, whose praise is always need-based? Radha and the Gopikas, Prahlada etc., are there, who love Him with total surrender and prepared to even sacrifice their lives to please Him. Does He require the love of these human beings, which is always apparent[11] like the water in a mirage? There are many devotees like Hanuman, Garuda, and Adi Shesha to serve Him continuously without a trace of aspiration for any fruit in return. Does He require the service of these human beings who fear to serve in advance and ask God to give the fruit first and only then offer service?
He is the infinite ocean of bliss and is giving divine happiness to the devotees, who are simply present near Him. Does He require the happiness from any human being, which is just momentary? The Veda says that God has no desire for anything from anybody. He creates the divine play just to show what you are to yourself in practice, because you always boast about yourself, your faith, love, surrender and sacrifice to God. He just wants to show you to yourself so that you will realize the truth about yourself and will take the necessary steps for your further spiritual effort. God wants that all the souls should live in peace and harmony with each other in society and make Pravritti as a strong stage for His divine play with His devotees. To rectify the Pravritti of souls and to achieve a peaceful society with mutual love for each other, God always puts all His efforts.
Except for this one aim, God has no other intention or selfish motive. Krishna projected Himself as God only to make Arjuna rectify his behavior in Pravritti. Otherwise, never He projected Himself as God at anytime in His life. Even if He did miracles, He always tried to hide them by giving some natural interpretations of the miraculous events. He showed His divine power only to punish the evil forces, which disturb society. He wanted to establish the existence of the divine administration through His super powers so that the future would be safe at least due to the fear of God. God always hides Himself on earth so that He can take some rest without being disturbed and can enjoy the life of a normal human being about which He is fascinated due to constant boredom in divine life. Unless there is some real requirement for the welfare of society, He never projects His divinity. He is happy if all the souls are happy in love and harmony.
Shri Baba always tried to rectify the Pravritti of society, for which alone, He projected His divinity through miracles. He never said that He alone is God and that others should worship Him, even though it is real that He alone is God as the contemporary human incarnation. He always addressed the public as embodiments of His divine soul. It means that He is treating all human beings as forms of God. By this address, He pacifies the ego and jealousy of the human beings towards Him at the very outset. He said that unless the soul rectified Pravritti and raised itself from unjust animal nature to its normal human nature, how could it rise to divine nature? Shankara used the concept of Advaita to change atheists into theists. Baba used the same concept to rectify the Pravritti of human beings and restore the normal human nature in society.
Only a few blessed souls get deeply interested in God and enter Nivritti after tasting the divine nature of God. God opposes them and tries to keep them in Pravritti alone. But having tasted the infinite bliss of God, the devotees of Nivritti are prepared even to sacrifice their lives like drug-addicted people who are restricted from using drugs! Finding the rigidity in their love to Him, God embraces them and they enter His inner circle. When Krishna asked the Gopikas to return back from Nivritti, they told Him that they will jump into River Yamuna and sacrifice their lives, if Krishna rejected them.
God never tries for devotees. Devotees alone try for God. Sugar does not search for ants. Ants search for sugar. The sweetness of sugar is an inherent quality of sugar and sugar cannot become salty to avoid the invasion of ants! Sugar hides itself in a tight iron box. Similarly, God hides in human form and covers Himself with a tight cover of Maya and sometimes even exhibits negative Maya to escape from devotees. It is meaningless and the climax of foolishness to say that God tries for devotees. Only people who do not know the divine knowledge speak like that. They say that Shri Baba tried to attract more number of people by making such a controversial scene since the number of His devotees had decreased recently. These people who talk like this always measure God with the standards of a politician, whom they observe frequently in their daily lives. They compare God in human form to a political leader, who makes some controversial scenes in public just to raise his image. God says in the Gita that ignorant people insult Him when He comes in human form, due to their ignorance of the God component in the human incarnation. The Veda says that if you miss your contemporary human incarnation here, you will miss the Lord, who is called as Father of heaven, in energetic form in the upper world also.
[1] Thoughts or wishes (Samkalpa) and various counteracting thoughts or doubts (Vikalpa) constitute the mind.
[2] We can never even think about God.
[3] The objection to basic inert energy being the source of the universe is that some intelligence or planning entity is necessary to design and plan the creation of such complexity and intricacy. How can energy, governed by the laws of physics, lead to such a complex universe, by mere permutation and combinations and probabilities? The counter argument is that if you give it a long enough time, the universe can get ‘created’ on its own, no matter how small the small the probability of an event (or of the creation of the entire design of the universe) is.
[4] cheating
[5] Divine Special Knowledge is (indcative of) God.
[6] Love is (indicative of) God
[7] Bliss is (indicative of) God
[8] God’s wish materializes or becomes real. The creation is a materialization of His will. All miracles are also manifestations of His will.
[9] Atheists say that sometimes God responds to your prayers by a miracle and sometimes He does not. Since there is no predictable and definitive relation between your prayers and God’s response, the very concept of God is wrong. The ‘miraculous’ responses to your prayers were simply coincidental.
[10] Relatively lower. The hierarchy being normal, higher, highest.
[11] Unreal
★ ★ ★ ★ ★