Please refute the narcissist allegation on Prophet.

[Shri Anil asked: Some challenges against Holy Prophet Muhammad. Pādanamaskāram Swami. A person named Ali Sina runs a website (https://www.faithfreedom.org/sinas-challenge/) in which he challenges anybody who disprove his claims about Holy Muhammad. He says: If you do not like this site and want me to remove it disprove my charges against Muhammad logically. Not only will I remove the site, I will publicly announce that Islam is a true religion. I will also pay $50,000 U.S. dollars to anyone who can disprove any of the accusations that I have made against Muhammad.

Swami, I am reproducing three of his accusations as given below:

1. Ali Sina says that the following are some of the claims Muhammad made about Himself in the hadith hence it shows that Muhammad was a narcissist.

1. The very first thing that Allâh Almighty ever created was My soul
2. First of all things, the Lord created My mind
3. I am from Allâh, and the believers are from Me
4. Just as Allâh created Me noble, He also gave Me noble characters
5. Were it not for You, [O Muhammad] I would not have created the universe.

Ali Sina says when compare the above to the words of Jesus, who when someone called him “good master,” Jesus objected and said, “Why do You call me good? No one is good—except God alone.”

Question: Ali Sina accuses Holy Muhammad as a narcissist. I request You to give a reply on the above allegations.]

Swami Replied:-

1)  My soul means the soul of soul. When God merges with a human being (both body and soul), the human incarnation results. The word “My” itself means the soul of the selected human being with which God is going to merge. Don’t think that “My” means simply body and God Himself is the direct soul present in the body. This is common to every human incarnation.

2)  Mind is awareness or soul and it is said that God created His mind, which means that His awareness or soul is created by God. Hence, this does not mean that the soul present in His body is directly God.

3)  Allah is the unimaginable God, who is the creator and can’t be approached directly for worship. The soul of this person (Prophet Mohammad) is charged by the unimaginable God. Hence, devotees come to Allah, who is merged with this soul because this soul has a body surrounding it, which is a good facility for worshipping God in human form. The devotees coming to this human incarnation are directly coming to Allah or unimaginable God. Since this human incarnation preaches Spiritual knowledge, the ordinary human beings become devotees of God and this is the meaning of the statement that believers are from the human incarnation.

4)  The human incarnation is noble and due to this reason, the unimaginable God (Allah) selected such noble human devotee as His medium. The devotees of the human incarnation also become noble due to the excellent Spiritual knowledge preached by it.

5)  When the human incarnation addresses Himself, it means that God is saying that creation was created by Him for the self-entertainment only.

Jesus is the same as Mohammad because both are human incarnations of unimaginable God or Father of heaven. When a devotee addressed one human incarnation as a good master, it means that the devotee has not identified the divinity of human incarnation. The devotee is considering the human incarnation as a good human being becoming good preacher. For such a person, the human incarnation will not reveal His divinity and behaves as a good co-human being only. Hence, Jesus told that only God is good and not any human being because any human being contains the three qualities (Sattvam, Rajas and Tamas) and hence, must contain some evil nature of Rajas and Tamas qualities also.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★